FINWIRES · TerminalLIVE
FINWIRES

Commerzbank Rejects UniCredit's Transformation Plan With Combination for Being 'Hostile, Misleading'

-- UniCredit (UCG.MI) on Monday presented a transformation plan for Commerzbank (CBK.F), outlining potential benefits of their merger, which the German lender dismissed as continued "hostile tactics and misleading characterisation."

UniCredit, which holds 26.04% of Commerzbank's voting rights through shares and 3.31% through instruments, pitched a new Unlocked approach to refocus Commerzbank on its core markets of Germany and Poland instead of the lender's "aggressive and riskier" international expansion under its Momentum plan. The suitor said the new approach will prioritize the German Mittelstand and families, raise investments in the frontline, technology and the adoption of artificial intelligence, while targeting efficiencies in non-core international network, senior overheads, operations, and more.

Under Unlocked, Commerzbank could reach a net profit of 5.1 billion euros by 2028, above the consensus of 4.5 billion euros under the German bank's Momentum strategy, UniCredit said, adding that Commerzbank is "ill-prepared" to compete with the US and fintech entrants in Germany, while being overly focused on short-term delivery and partly relying on favorable interest-rate conditions and non-core international growth to offset higher-than-target operating expenses in 2025.

UniCredit also countered Commerzbank's remarks that its takeover offer provided no adequate premium, arguing that consensus forecasts imply an over 5% stronger performance after a combination compared with the Momentum strategy. It added that Commerzbank has declined further premium discussions and engagement on deal details.

Commerzbank rejected those assertions, saying the offer still excludes a "market-standard" premium and describing the transformation proposal as a "speculative attempt to dismantle" its business model following what it called more than 18 months of unsolicited stake-building by UniCredit.

"What UniCredit described today is not a convincing combination case. It is an attempted restructuring proposal by a direct competitor, cutting into the core value chain of the German Mittelstand regarding its international business and trade finance. It comprises a compression of Commerzbank's cost base modelled on HypoVereinsbank, and a reorientation away from the Mittelstand franchise that defines the Bank's competitive position. At the same time, UniCredit has not revealed any substantive new details on its actual combination plan -- be it actual levers, cost-to-achieve or timeline. This has been repeatedly requested by Commerzbank and been denied to date," Commerzbank argued.

The lender added that any potential combination benefits would likely take "a couple of years," with implementation possibly starting between 2029 and 2030, and said it will present updated targets and its 2030 strategy alongside first-quarter results on May 8.

Related Articles

Sectors

Update: Gold Moves Lower Again as Dollar Rises On U.S. Retail Sales Surge and Hopes of An End To Middle East War

(Updates prices.)Gold prices were down a second day midafternoon Tuesday as the dollar rose after U.S. retail sales rose above expectations last month, while talks between the United States and Iran could see an end to the Middle East war that has sent the price of oil and other commodities higher.Gold for May delivery was last seen down US$105.50 to US$4,723.30 per ounce.The U.S. Census Bureau on Tuesday said March retail sales rose by 1.7%, up from a revised 0.7% a month earlier and ahead of the consensus estimate for a rise of 1.5%, according to Marketwatch. The rise was the highest in more than three years, CNN reported, but came on a record jump in gasoline prices due to the U.S. war on Iran.Talks to end the war are expected to begin in Pakistan as a two-week ceasefire is set to end tomorrow. A deal could see an end to the closure of the Strait of Hormuz and lower high prices for oil and other commodities trapped in the Persian Gulf. However, Iran has not publicly confirmed it will send negotiators to Pakistan to meet with the United States, though the Wall Street Journal reports Iran has told mediators it will send a team to the talks."Gold is consolidating as traders assess the prospects for renewed US-Iran talks and the approaching ceasefire deadline. Its near-term trajectory remains closely linked to developments in the Middle East, given the potential spillover into inflation expectations, the dollar, bond yields, and US rate outlook," Saxo Bank wrote.The dollar was higher early, with the ICE dollar index was last seen up 0.33 points to 98.43. Treasury yields were also higher, with the yield on the U.S. two-year note up 6.3 basis points to 3.788%, while the yield on the 10-year note was paying 4.297%, up 4.3 points.

$GCK6$GLD
Sectors

Sector Update: Consumer Stocks Ease in Afternoon Trading

Consumer stocks were lower Tuesday afternoon, with the State Street Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLP) down 0.3% and the State Street Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR ETF (XLY) decreasing 0.2%.In sector news, Redbook US same-store sales rose by 6.7% from a year earlier in the week ended April 18 after a 7% year-over-year increase in the previous week. "Some retailers reported weaker year-over-year Easter sales, facing challenging comparisons to last year's pre-Easter shopping week in April," Redbook noted. Sales of home improvement items and outdoor merchandise picked up as spring began while household basics, food and consumables held steady.In corporate news, Tractor Supply (TSCO) reported Q1 results that missed Wall Street's projections amid a below-average performance of its companion animal product business. Its shares dropped past 10%.D.R. Horton's (DHI) fiscal Q2 results came in better than expected, although the homebuilder tempered its full-year revenue outlook. Its shares rose past 7%.Estee Lauder (EL) has hired JPMorgan (JPM) to come up with a financing package of about 5 billion euros ($5.88 billion) to fund its takeover of Puig, Spanish business newspaper Expansion reported Tuesday. Estee Lauder shares were down 1.4%.

$DHI$EL$TSCO
Commodities

Zelenskyy Says Druzhba Pipeline Restored, Fuel Supplies Secured for April-May

Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said Tuesday that the Druzhba pipeline has been restored, as Kyiv pushes for energy funding and protection of its infrastructure.Zelenskyy said in a post on X that repair work on the Druzhba oil pipeline segment damaged by a Russian strike has been completed, allowing operations to resume.He cautioned that "no one can currently guarantee that Russia will not repeat attacks," despite efforts to restore pipeline functionality and safeguard infrastructure.The pipeline restoration is linked to the expected unblocking of a European Union support package already approved by the European Council, he said.Zelenskyy added Ukraine has fulfilled its commitments under initial European Union negotiation clusters and called for continued sanctions pressure on Russia alongside efforts to diversify Europe's energy supplies.Ukraine is also coordinating closely with partners to ensure stable energy cooperation as global disruptions linked to the Iran conflict impact fuel markets, Zelenskyy added.He noted that agreed fuel supply volumes for April and May have been fully secured.Ukraine is also preparing for an Energy Ramstein meeting later this week, aimed at accelerating funding efforts for energy system recovery and strengthening protection of critical infrastructure, he added.